Spin Master Earnings: Season Scrooged Ahead of Holidays; Melissa & Doug Tie-Up Preserves 2024 Growth
No-moat Spin Master TOY failed to escape the recent spending weakness that has plagued the consumer discretionary landscape, revising its gross product sales, or GPS, outlook to decline at a high-single-digit rate from flat to slightly down prior. This implies fourth-quarter GPS that still rise at a high-teens clip, significantly better than our other narrow-moat company forecasts, which include a high-teens decline at Hasbro’s consumer product segment and low-double-digit increase in GPS at Mattel. We expect to reduce our CAD 50 fair value estimate in response to a weaker near-term outlook for GPS that we believe will persist into 2024. However, the full decline will be partially offset by the addition of Melissa & Doug in our model. We have added roughly $450 million in projected 2024 sales from Melissa & Doug to our estimate, below the $490 million the brand captured in 2022 to account for the slowdown seen broadly across toy categories. As such, we plan to adjust our intrinsic value lower by around $3 but still view shares as significantly undervalued.
Spin Master’s third-quarter performance was solid, with total GPS up 14% with all three creative segments capturing growth. Toy GPS rose a strong 10%, but entertainment impressed, rising 71% thanks to Paw Patrol’s movie release, a factor we think will be a key to growth over the next few quarters given the upcoming recognition of the direct-to-consumer release and ongoing inbound license flows. Furthermore, digital appears to have found its return to growth in consumers, which drove segment sales 31% higher—monthly average users on Toca Life World rose 12%, while Sago Mini (which represents the most digital users) and Originator contracted at just a low-single-digit rate. Adjusted EBITDA margin rose 620 basis points, to 33.1%, although we concede some of this was attributable to the mix of sales (with entertainment strong) rather than structural changes in the business.
The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article. Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.