Skip to Content

Voting Against
Plastic Packaging

Plastic packaging pollutes, and food companies are the biggest users. Shareholder activists have pressured the industry for years, with little success. But recent events suggest a change in investor attitudes.

PLASTIC POLLUTION

Since 1950, global plastic production has risen 150-fold to 350 million metric tons, with packaging accounting for 40% of total use. The manufacture of plastic generates greenhouse gases, heavy metals, and particulates, and discarded plastics pollute ecosystems. The food industry has the biggest consumers. Coca-Cola, for example, uses 3 million tons each year, according to Break Free from Plastic, an advocacy group.

PRESSING FOR CHANGE

Investors who want to change food-industry policies can practice active ownership by voting on shareholder resolutions that address packaging. Since 2015, U.S. shareholders have voted on 32 resolutions targeting plastic-packaging practices in the food industry, according to Morningstar Sustainalytics. Until recently, none of them had achieved a majority vote.

PACKAGING POLICY

Last year, a resolution recommending that DuPont report annually on the effectiveness of its policies to reduce plastic pollution achieved 81% of shareholders' support. Five months later, DuPont said it was joining Operation Clean Sweep blue, a plastics-industry program that commits members to managing and reporting on plastic pollution.

A MIXED BAG

This year, activists withdrew plastic packaging resolutions at Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, and Kraft Heinz after these companies agreed to changes, according to Morningstar Sustainalytics' Engagement Services, which provides shareholder resolution research and voting recommendations. Resolutions went to a vote at four food companies: Jack in the Box (where 95% of shareholders voted in favor), McDonald’s (42%), Kroger (38%), and Tyson Foods (14%). Not counting Tyson family holdings, 57% of Tyson Foods’ shareholders supported the resolution.

Majority Shareholder Support for Plastic Packaging Resolutions 2015—21

Data Source: Morningstar Sustainalytics Proxy Data Feed

Legal Disclaimer


MORNINGSTAR EXPERTS

Meet the Morningstar Experts who are shaping our understanding of The Future of Food.

Learn more

Read more about Morningstar’s ESG Solutions or dig deeper into our sustainable investing research and insights.