Unlocking the Power of 351 Conversion: ETFs, Tax Efficiency, and the Future of Investing

Exchange-traded funds have revolutionized investing, offering unparalleled tax efficiency and accessibility. Wes Gray, the founder of Alpha Architect and ETF Architect, has been at the forefront of ETF innovation, particularly in the realm of SMA to ETF conversions. His insights shed light on how the ETF wrapper facilitates tax-aware strategies, the growing demand for tax-aware re-packaging, and the potential regulatory risks associated with these benefits.

You can listen to this and other episodes of the Big Picture in Practice podcast by Morningstar on all major streaming platforms. You can keep up with the latest episodes by subscribing to our Big Picture in Practice Newsletter.

Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | Pandora

Wes Gray’s background is as unconventional as it is impressive. A Marine Corps combat veteran and University of Chicago finance PhD, he has navigated both the academic and financial worlds with precision. After launching Alpha Architect as a quantitative investing firm, he quickly recognized the tax benefits of ETFs and transitioned from separately managed accounts to ETFs in 2013. This shift led to the founding of ETF Architect, a white-label ETF platform that simplifies ETF launches for sponsors.

Historically, launching an ETF has been a costly and complex endeavor, often dominated by large financial institutions with deep pockets and extensive regulatory resources. However, Wes has worked to lower these barriers, making it easier for smaller firms, independent advisors, and asset managers to enter the ETF marketplace.

“ETFs are amazing for capital owners. They are tax-efficient, transparent, and low-cost. Who wouldn’t want to get their money into that vehicle if it was feasible?” Wes emphasizes.

ETFs have become a cornerstone of modern investing due to their liquid nature. Compared to mutual funds, ETFs offer lower costs and fewer taxable events, making them attractive to a wide range of investors. However, they are not without limitations. While ETFs work exceptionally well for broad market exposure and liquidity, they can be less effective in niche strategies that require active management or alternative assets.

The ETF wrapper minimizes taxable events by using in-kind transactions to manage redemptions and rebalance portfolios. This structure allows investors to defer capital gains taxes, making ETFs a preferred choice for tax-sensitive investors.

While the tax efficiency of ETFs is a major benefit, it also comes with some challenges. If not properly structured, ETFs can face issues like tracking errors, liquidity constraints, or increased regulatory attention. As with any investment vehicle, managing these risks is key to maintaining the tax efficiency that makes ETFs so attractive.

One of the most compelling trends in asset management today is the transition from separately managed accounts (SMAs) to ETFs. These SMA to ETF conversions offer significant advantages, including enhanced tax efficiency, scalability, and improved market accessibility.

Many investors hold significant unrealized gains in SMAs, which can create a tax burden when assets are sold. Using Section 351 of the Internal Revenue Code, investors can transfer assets from SMAs into ETFs without immediately triggering capital gains taxes. This allows them to maintain their cost basis and holding period while benefiting from ETFs’ tax advantages.

Wes highlights the growing demand for SMA to ETF conversions, and the challenge investors face. “Our job as ETF salespeople is to help clients move assets into a better space. The world is moving to ETFs, but the biggest hurdle is the tax liability when selling current assets to buy into ETFs,” he says.

By enabling clients to transfer assets without realizing capital gains, the Section 351 conversion process opens up a range of new possibilities for tax-efficient portfolio management.

Innovations like the TAX ETF are democratizing access to tax-efficient investing. TAX was designed to help large-scale 351 conversions. TAX appeals to high-net-worth individuals, registered investment advisors or RIAs, and asset managers seeking to transition into a more tax-efficient structure. Compared to tax-managed SMAs and exchange funds, TAX offers greater flexibility and lower costs while preserving the tax advantages of ETFs.

This innovation opens doors for investors who previously faced high barriers to ETF entry. By consolidating assets in a single, tax-efficient vehicle, TAX allows investors to optimize portfolio management while minimizing capital gains liabilities.

Despite their advantages, ETFs are not immune to regulatory scrutiny. The tax benefits ETFs enjoy today stem from a complex web of tax policies and historical precedents. Some lawmakers have even proposed closing tax loopholes that benefit ETFs.

While these concerns are valid, eliminating ETF tax benefits could have unintended consequences. Unlike mutual funds, which can impose taxable events on all shareholders, ETFs ensure individual investors bear their tax burdens. This structure aligns with sound public policy by preventing externalities and promoting long-term investing.

ETFs serve a broad investor base, from retail investors to institutional clients. Unlike tax strategies that primarily benefit billionaires, ETF tax efficiency is widely accessible, making it politically challenging to dismantle.

ETFs have cemented their status as a dominant investment vehicle, and the rise of SMA to ETF conversions further reinforces their appeal. By leveraging Section 351 conversions, investors can transition into tax-efficient structures without triggering immediate capital gains taxes. Innovations like TAX and white-label ETF solutions continue democratizing access to tax-efficient investing.

Regulatory scrutiny will remain a factor to watch. However, given ETFs’ widespread benefits, legislative changes will likely aim to level the playing field rather than eliminate tax advantages altogether. For now, ETFs remain one of the most powerful tools for tax-aware investing, offering efficiency and flexibility in an ever-changing financial landscape.